REPLICA Whispers in the Library - Eau de Toilette

Amazing scent

Soo good. Warm and cosy, and evokes a fuzzy feeling. One of my favourites.

Smells like an old memory

Smells so good, the smell changes to more vanilla-y after a few hours but initially it smells like an old library with pots of plants somewhere. It definitely is for you if you like the whole dark academia aesthetic! I would say it leans more feminine than unisex in my opinion.

Signature Scent for 2 Years and Counting

This has been my signature fragrance since I tried it in 2021 and I can't imagine ever changing that. The woodsy/vanilla notes oxidize well on my skin and settle into a very feminine, very memorable fragrance. if I could find travel sizes of this I would have one in each of my bags.

Warm & cozy

I’m pretty sure this fragrance has been discontinued which is a shame because it is a gorgeous scent! It is a warm, dry, cozy but also elegant fragrance. The name is perfect.

Perfect dupe for old Gucci Guilty

I was so sad when Gucci changed their formula for the “Guilty” perfumes. The 2015 version was my favorite. This perfume smells 90% the same! Only issue is it’s not very long lasting

Cozy, woody comforting scent. Makes me feel like I’m reading a book in a local coffee shop on a weekday afternoon

Lovely but...

This a lovely woody and spicy perfume at first. I have to say that it changes (for me) within the first 5-10 minutes to more sweet scent which I don't mind. I love this perfume but, like many others said before me, it isn't long lasting which is disappointing considering the price point. Still, I do recommend this product.

Unbeatable price

Beautiful fragrance and the price was unbeatable

Carmex

I love the idea and vibe behind this fragrance, and liked it... until my brain made the connection that it smells pretty much identical to Carmex lip balm (the OG kind in the little pot). I had to return it because every time I smelled it I was being reminded of having coldsores. If it weren't for that, I would have loved it. Longevity is moderate.

change in formula?

even 3 years ago this smelled totally different. I tried this in a travel sized bottle first, and back then it smelled like freshly waxed floors, like a new library with lots of public funding. I realize floor wax isn't everyone's thing, but I enjoyed it. now it smells... dusty and spicy. like it doesn't have the gumption to commit to a scent profile, it comes off a bit stale to me. now I have most of a full sized bottle and no desire to use it.

Please bring it back!

This is my favorite scent from MM Replica collection. Please bring it back!!

Could be improved on longevity

I quite like it offers a vanillaish note but I feel like it’s not such potent as it’s similar counterparts