Master Pigment Pro® Pencil - Crayon yeux

I bought this pencil in soft brown and absolutely loved it. it was creamy, pigmented, easy to use and stayed put all day. I was so impressed I bought the bronze shade but this one is awful. it is so so dry, it drags on the lid and doesn't smudge out at all. I thought I was just unlucky and got a bad one but the soft brown one is now going dry and hard to work with. I have only had them a couple of months and they are stored properly and the lids are put back on tight. such a shame as the colours are lovely and I would of highly recommended the brown if it hadn't dried out the way it has.

Too dark of a brown

It’s a nice pencil, it has a good consistency and also stays on a long time. I returned it in the end because the color of brown is too dark. I like my brown eyeliner to look brown, not black. With this one you can’t hardly tell that it’s not black. They just need a more medium tone of brown. For the price I expect perfection.

Brown turned ORANGE/RED????

Upon blending/smudging out the brown eyeliner turned bright orange/red on my eyes. Like neon.

Can live without -regret buying

Been looking for a perfect brown liner saw Mario video raving about this liner he said it last long on the waterline - Didn’t stay on my waterline after 2 mins of putting it on

Not as good as it used to be.

I used to love this eye liner but lately it stops working when there is tons of pencil left and the pencil disappears and I need to sharpen over and over to find it again.

Stays put!

Stays put! This pencil is soft enough that is doesn’t pull across my eyelid but not so soft that it breaks or clumps. It is also long lasting and a dark brown colour.

Once you sharpen it . It hurts to use

Total rubbish , bought it twice cause i thought i got a bad one the fitst time and everyone raves about it . Waste of money

I have never had an eye stye in my life!

I got this brown pencil 2 months ago and I used this eye pencil for the first time (mostly as eyeliner, barely on the waterline), and shortly after I developed a stye. I didn’t think much of it. Recently I used the same pencil again on waterline , and now I have the worst eye stye I’ve ever experienced — severe swelling and pain. This is the only new eye product I introduced, so I strongly believe it triggered the reaction. Unfortunately, I cannot recommend this product, especially if you have sensitive eyes.

Love anything from Makeup by Mario

As a brown skin girl, I can say that it is a must have for everyone who has dark eyelids.

not ideal

doesn’t blend as easily as i hoped it would for smoking out my bottom eyeliner. also, if you want to use an eyeliner on your waterline don’t get this. it barely applies on the waterline and its not very soft.

beaucoup trop gras

déçue de ce crayon, l'effet est hyper gras et coulant, il a fuit dans la journée même en essayant de l estomper

amazing!

this eyeliner is really good and pigmented. it lasts a long time and it easy to use.